2020 #CCEawards Showcase: Building NXBuildings #CCEawards 2020 Canadian Consulting Engineering Awards airtightness B+H Architects BECx Bird Construction Building Envelope Building Envelope Commissioning Building NX CaGBC Canada Green Building Council code consulting cooling curtain wall DCV demand controlled ventilation Electrical engineering Energy Modelling energy-efficient EnerPHit Engineering a Better Canada Award geotechnical heating Humer College HVAC IAQ Indoor air quality insulation lighting mechanical engineering Morrison Hershfield passive design Passive House Passive House Institute PHI RDH retrofit roof solar Structural engineering sustainability thermal bridging thermal continuity triple glazing variable refrigerant flow VRF walls windows zero-carbon building design
“This really showcases the forefront of engineering in making existing building stock sustainable to meet Canada’s carbon reduction targets. These are the buildings of the future.” – Jury
Tree for Life Award and Award of Excellence Winner: Morrison Hershfield
The transformation of the aging Building NX at Toronto’s Humber College is the first retrofit in Canada to achieve Zero-Carbon Building Design certification from the Canada Green Building Council (CaGBC) and is currently on track to achieve the first Passive House (PH) EnerPHit certification for a non-residential building in Canada.
A complete building envelope retrofit, a solar photovoltaic system and energy-efficient upgrades to heating, cooling and lighting systems, all undertaken while the building remained fully occupied, have transformed it into one of the most energy-efficient buildings anywhere in North America.
Morrison Hershfield provided structural, electrical and mechanical engineering, building envelope, PH and code consulting for the project.
Passive design strategies
Previously, Building NX suffered a number of systematic failures, such as air infiltration, water penetration, condensation and temperature fluctuations.
Passive design strategies for the building enclosure were maximized to significantly reduce the heating and cooling required. These focused on the airtightness and thermal continuity of the building envelope, which now features an ultra-high-performance skin, engineered transitions for greater air control to mitigate thermal bridging (especially at wall-to-window, wall-to-wall and wall-to-roof points), high-performance triple glazing in PH-certified window frames and curtain walls, excavation to install exterior below-grade insulation and removal of an inefficient skylight.
Testing and an extensive Building Envelope Commissioning (BECx) program were implemented throughout construction, including whole building air leakage testing, which found fewer than the 0.6 air changes per hour at 50 Pa pressure (0.6 ACH50) of the PH Institute’s (PHI’s) performance threshold for new construction; PHI requires only 1.0 ACH50 for retrofit applications.
The new HVAC system uses local heating and cooling and heat pumps for space conditioning and demand controlled ventilation (DCV) for CO2 differential control. It decouples the ventilation air from the building’s heating and air conditioning, while maintaining fresh air distribution throughout.
Building NX was also decoupled from the campus’ central utility plant, using an air-source variable refrigerant flow (VRF) system to recover and transfer heat between zones—working like a water-source VRF, but exchanging heat with ambient air instead of using the plant’s water loop. Two new air-cooled VRF heat pumps were installed on the roof and fan-coil units were provided for each thermal zone to keep the temperature consistent across the building.
The retrofit has reduced energy use intensity by 70% to 64 kWh/m2), heating energy by 97% and associated greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 90%. The five-storey, 4,500-m2 building now has a peak heating demand similar to a single family home.
Also, the new 25-kW solar PV system will generate an estimated 31,500 kWh per year, more than the building will consume. The excess will be fed upstream.
The Building NX retrofit demonstrates to owners everywhere the benefits of applying PH principles to increase a building’s resilience, reduce its energy needs and operational costs and optimize comfort. Indeed, occupants now experience more ideal temperatures, improved indoor air quality (IAQ) and ample daylight.
Humber’s own students also participated across multiple program disciplines, with a team of them completing a design in parallel with the actual retrofit. The project team shared knowledge, provided feedback at design presentations and helped faculty evaluate the students’ work.
Low-carbon retrofits to existing buildings have tremendous potential to address the effects of climate change. Humber is investing in energy efficiency methodologies and new performance benchmarks to achieve its own ambitious sustainability goals by 2034, such as cutting energy and water use in half and reducing GHG emissions by 30%, but also seeks to provide an example to encourage similar projects elsewhere in the future.
As CaGBC puts it, Building NX now serves “as a national example of how to retrofit to zero-carbon.”
Award-winning firm (building envelope consulting, Passive House (PH) sustainability consulting, structural engineering, electrical engineering, mechanical engineering, code consulting): Morrison Hershfield, Markham, Ont. (Steven Murray, P.Eng.; Alejandro Ortega, P.Eng.; Sylvie Gayed, P.Eng.; Felix Chen, P.Eng.; Dana Scherf, P.Eng; Zane Biblow, P.Eng. David Kankaras, MBA).
Owner: Humber College.